Definitely worth it, the MSI Katana is known to have hinge issues.
Absolutely, the MSI Katana has been problematic.
As a former Alienware user who now generally doesn’t recommend them, I’d still say go for the Alienware over the MSI. It’s the lesser of two evils here.
Hero said:
As a former Alienware user who now generally doesn’t recommend them, I’d still say go for the Alienware over the MSI. It’s the lesser of two evils here.
It says a lot when someone who isn’t a fan of Alienware still recommends it over MSI.
Alienware has great build quality and performance, though it’s bulky. MSI, while more portable, doesn’t match up in build quality. Paying extra for Alienware might be worth it in this case.
Could you specify which Alienware model and its CPU details? (e.g., Intel Core i7-265K)
Corey said:
Could you specify which Alienware model and its CPU details? (e.g., Intel Core i7-265K)
It’s equipped with an Intel Core i7 155H. That’s all the info available on the product page.
@Corey
Thanks for this comparison, really helpful 
@Corey
Lower TDP is good for battery life, but having more threads like the 8945HS is better for multitasking. Though for gaming, the core speed is what matters, not just the thread count.
Lake said:
@Corey
Lower TDP is good for battery life, but having more threads like the 8945HS is better for multitasking. Though for gaming, the core speed is what matters, not just the thread count.
Ryzen may have good benchmark scores, but in real-world performance, especially unplugged, it doesn’t measure up to Intel.
@Lex
Actually, AMD CPUs tend to be more power-efficient, which should translate to better battery life.
Jesse said:
@Lex
Actually, AMD CPUs tend to be more power-efficient, which should translate to better battery life.
My personal experience with AMD on battery hasn’t been great. It feels significantly slower, which doesn’t match the high benchmarks for battery life.
@Lex
I’ve used AMD in several new gaming laptops and personally prefer them over Intel for their balance of performance and battery efficiency.
Jesse said:
@Lex
I’ve used AMD in several new gaming laptops and personally prefer them over Intel for their balance of performance and battery efficiency.
We’ll have to agree to disagree. I find Intel offers better performance when not plugged in.
Without a doubt. The build quality on the MSI Katana doesn’t compare to Alienware.
Had an MSI back in 2017, had to replace several parts within the first year. Not a great experience.
The MSI Katana feels flimsy. Alienware would be a better choice, though if there’s a deal on a Lenovo Legion, consider that as an even better option.
Appreciate all the feedback! Also, is buying an open box model too risky?